What do boys want?
Our school libraries will remain largely unused by
boys if we don’t have what they genuinely want to read. There
may well be many books in our libraries that will benefit boys, broadening
their experience, helping them mature, widening their vocabulary, giving
them confidence, and aiding the rest of their learning; books achieve such
things not by their high literary quality – though some of them will
have this – but by being read.
Our challenge is to value boys’ reading tastes,
whatever they are; to feed demand for the popular; and to tempt boys by the very
best. Our libraries need a hugely varied reading diet, because boys,
like all children, have hugely varied needs and demands.
We can never be confident that we know enough about
which books boys want to see in their school library – or even more
crucially, about which books would draw in those who never visit it.
Our own guesswork is not good enough – we need to learn from
the users.
Talk to boys; if you are genuine about your need to
know their reading tastes, they’ll respond to this – though
allow for them sometimes telling you what you want to hear! Floor
walking in the library, personal interaction, observation, surveys,
suggestion boxes, requests, online polls on the school/library website,
etc. – all can tell us what boys want from their library.
Be careful to distinguish between so-called reluctant
readers and boys with genuine reading difficulty. Boys may not use
your library for either reason, and although the situations sometimes
overlap (and some materials may be useful for both) it’s important to
identify individual boys’ circumstances.
What succeeds in one school may not succeed in
another. Your school’s profile is unique – and it changes
every year – so you’ll need to keep the ideas changing,
sometimes revisiting them, and adapting them to suit your situation.
Best of all, allow the boys freedom to organise events and
initiatives themselves, for each other.
Start from where boys are, not where you would like
them to be. Once you’ve engaged boys’ interest in an
idea, they’ll amaze you by how much they do.
Here are some frequent conclusions from surveys and
experience; test them with boys in your school:
- Boys are more likely
to read for a purpose, if they can ‘see the point in it’.
Margaret Meek’s conclusion that ‘To benefit from reading,
students need to work out what reading is for’1 is especially true of
boys.
- Boys often prefer
non-fiction; illustrated books; and ‘fun facts’ material.
- Boys frequently choose
books ‘because they feel they have to’, but may be more
susceptible than girls to recommendations from librarians and teachers.
- Boys are drawn to
fiction related to out of school interests – sport, computers, music.
- Boys enjoy fast-paced
stories, with plenty of action.
- Boys often have crazes
for the subject of the moment, and switch to new ones fast.
- Boys may have more
difficulty identifying themselves in stories.
- Children can seem like
‘grazers rather than diners’ in their reading, and boys in
particular will dip into books, lacking reading stamina.
- Boys visit libraries,
but to meet, browse, and play games. Far fewer of them take books
out.
Every one of these conclusions has exceptions!
Resist any habit of pigeonholing boys, and base your library’s
actions on your library’s readers.